Catholic churches told to hold masses for Tai Po fire victims

In an unexpected move amid police “concern” about memorial activities marking the first anniversary of the Tai Po deadly fire, the head of Hong Kong’s Catholic diocese has asked all of the city’s parishes to hold special masses and prayers for the victims later this month.
According to a notice issued by the Hong Kong Catholic Diocesan Liturgy Commission on last Friday (Nov 13), Cardinal Stephen Chow Sau-yan invited parishes in a letter to offer mass for the deceased on November 26.
The deadly blaze killed 168 people, including a firefighter, and left more than 1,900 families at the Wang Fuk Court housing estate homeless.
The church leader appealed for togetherness among parishes and their followers to pray for the victims at a time when an air of jitters and uncertainty mixed with tension swept across the religious circle with the first anniversary of the devastating fire drawing near.
◾Churches questioned by police
Earlier this week, two Catholic churches have reportedly been questioned by police over plans to hold a first-anniversary memorial mass for victims of the fire.
Immaculate Heart of Mary Church in Tai Po was questioned by police twice after announcing a special service this Sunday. The church has since replaced the anniversary mass with a general ceremony for “the brothers and sisters who died in the past year,” according to a Facebook post on last Tuesday.
On a Commercial Radio show on Tuesday, Our Lady of Mount Carmel parish priest Father Thomas Law said November was a month of remembrance for the Catholic community, and that the church held such a memorial every year.
Asked whether the mass would address victims of the Tai Po fire, Law said that anyone who wished to pray for them might do so, and that there was “no need to add or subtract.” He said he had not been contacted by police.
But hours after the radio segment aired, Law confirmed to reporters that he had since been questioned by three police officers asking about details of the mass and how many people would attend. He said that police did not threaten him, and that they were just concerned and “curious.”
◾Jitters turn into fears
While consoling the souls of the departed, Cardinal Chow said in the letter “Let us also pray that the Lord may teach us to practise charity, uphold the truth, and work for justice.”
Law told the Chinese-language Ming Pao the cardinal’s letter has “set the direction” for everyone “in the midst of storm.”
Police Commissioner Joe Chow said on last Saturday police have always had the responsibility of getting to know more about plans of public activities from the relevant organisers. Whether the organisers hold the activities is a matter for them, he said. He did not comment on the reported “concerns” police have expressed to churches.
Under existing law, the holding of public rallies and demonstrations need an application from the police for a letter of no-objection. Understandably, police are concerned about issues such as crowd control in public rallies. Masses in churches did not seem to be something on the radar screen of police. The Wang Fuk Court fire looks like an exception.
Though perhaps inconceivable to parishes and church-goers, police’s concern about the aftermath of the deadly fire is arguably not a surprise set against the background of their heightened concern about order and security in gatherings of citizens in the wake of the 2019 social movement.
Those concerns are so widely known, seemingly prompting many groups to have given up plans to hold public rallies and activities, stoking concern about the erosion of freedom of expression.
Civic activities, not to mention political activism, of the civil society have rubbed the sensitive nerves of the security-obsessed authorities and the loyalists. Jitters of crossing the political “red lines” inadvertently breed more jitters. Jitters turn into fears.
◾A shield to brave the rain and wind
Partly because of its nature, religious activities remain focused and resilient despite the seismic changes in the socio-political landscape after the 2019 political storm.
Reports of some churches faced questioning by police about their masses and prayers last week have raised concern about freedom of conscience and freedom of participation in religious activities under Basic Law Article 32.
By calling on all parishes to offer prayers to the Tai Po victims in an open letter, the Catholic diocese has given them a shield to brave the rain and wind, and to show charity, seek truth and justice at a time when they are needed most.
▌ [At Large] About the Author
Chris Yeung is a veteran journalist, a founder and chief writer of the now-disbanded CitizenNews; he now runs a daily news commentary channel on Youtube. He had formerly worked with the South China Morning Post and the Hong Kong Economic Journal.